Thanks for the good discussion about my last post. I decided to respond to a few of your comments and questions in a follow-up:
Comment
The first biblical mention of the spirit of God showing up in power
during a "worship service" was at pentecost (we just passed it). At
that service most of the unchurched said "they must be drunk". How many time has your church service ever been accused of being drunk recently?
I agree. But to be that free in worship means we might actually have to deviate from the bulletin occasionally. That's okay. Most people don't read the bulletin anyway.
...
Comment
My guess is that the things that are boring to teens are also boring to many adults.
Exactly. Only most adults will try to be polite and look like they're paying attention (except when they take an unplanned nap.)
...
Comment
Surely, Shane, you aren't suggesting that worship should be
entertaining? Because I hardly think entertainment should be a
consideration of worship.
Yes, that's exactly what I'm suggesting. Here are some dictionary definitions of entertain:
en·ter·tain (
n
t
r-t
n
)
v. tr. 1. To hold the attention of with something amusing or diverting.
2. To extend hospitality toward.
How are teens going to worship God with their minds if we can't get their attention and get them to focus on God? I think holding people's attention during a worship service is a good thing. Diversion is defined as distracting the attention from worrisome thoughts or cares. Shouldn't that happen when we worship God?
...
Comment
I know we're living in a different day and age, but I think the biggest
mistake we're making with this generation is feeling obligated to
entertain them every minute of every day.
Not every minute of every day, but wouldn't it great to be able to hold their attention for an hour or two a week?
...
Comment
They are not going elsewhere to be fed; as far as I can tell they are
just choosing to stay between the sheets on Sunday morning. And, I
place large measure of blame on parents who allow that to happen.
Does MTV blame the parents if teenagers tune out? Does Hollywood blame parents if teens skip the latest flick? No. They blame themselves and they fix whatever's wrong. And besides... what about unchurched kids who have unchurched parents?
...
Comment
Let them preach!!! They have some good things to say to us!!! Let them do children's sermons!!! Give them the tools and they will run with it. Let them serve in music!!! They often play it better than us!!! Let them at the tech team!!! They know it better than any of us. Let them work with the pastor to spice-up a message.
Sounds good to me, but are we really prepared to take their suggestions seriously and talk the older longtime members down from the tree when teens do something out of the box or make a mistake?
...
Comment
I don't think bongos and guitars in worship are a problem but you don't
have to forsake, as most churhes have now, all aspects of the historic
Christian faith to update your worship sevice. The gospel is timeless
and God doesn't need cool music for it to work.
There are a couple of problems with your argument: Style and substance are two different things. Tightening up a worship service, adding elements to engage younger generations and allowing freedom in the Spirit doesn't in any way forsake the historic Christian faith. So most churches have rejected all aspects of the historic Christian faith now? That's definitely an exaggeration. All music is new sometimes. The stuff in our hymnal was cutting edge at various points in time. And no, we don't need the latest music for God to work. But why settle for all old stuff when we have a church full of young artists who have much to contribute?
...
Comment
Shane, as some others have noted, my resistance to one of your
suggestions is that gathering for worship should never be made
"optional" for Christians.
But if it isn't optional, is it really worship? If it's forced on us, is it authentic? And is worship what happens at 11AM Sunday or should it be a lifestyle?
...
Comment
I think announcements can easily fall into that category! I prefer
that announcements be made BEFORE the prelude. Heck, they are always
printed in the bulletin anyway. Why does someone need to read the
announcements from the bulletin? If we are going to announce everything printed in the bulletin
anyway, why don't we just save a tree and quit printing the things.
Thank you. I couldn't have written it better myself.